Score: 4

"Needs more"

submission: First Breath

date: December 5, 2008

Well it needs more than just drums. Right now it's repetitive and empty. You should add some rhythm and melody above the drums.

Score: 7

"Interesting"

submission: Mega Man X - Dillo Trance

date: November 28, 2008

Interesting adaptation.

Would have liked to hear it get a little faster and upbeat at some point.

Score: 6

"Needs more"

submission: Warriors of Nareth

date: November 28, 2008

Needs more substance. For a passing song in an rpg, it's not bad though, just a little simple on an absolute scale. Reminds me of Jazz Jackrabbit for some reason. Haha.

Score: 5

"Not bad."

submission: [L.P] Remember

date: November 28, 2008

Not too bad. Needs some variety though, it's kind of hard to have to sit through three minutes of just about exactly the same thing over and over aside from some minor differences. You should make different segments of the song so it's more interesting.

It's a good start, just needs to be modeled a little better.

Score: 10

"Freakin better than the original."

submission: Fountain of Dreams remix

date: November 28, 2008

Not that you didn't already know that ;) Excellent variety, excellent arrangement, excellent voicing.

10/10 stars my friend.

Score: 8

"Great"

submission: Moon leght Day

date: July 25, 2008

A very different, original piece. You took a risk here - and it paid off. Very nice.